diff --git a/LightlessSync/UI/DownloadUi.cs b/LightlessSync/UI/DownloadUi.cs
index 37119e2..c54cf46 100644
--- a/LightlessSync/UI/DownloadUi.cs
+++ b/LightlessSync/UI/DownloadUi.cs
@@ -102,9 +102,9 @@ public class DownloadUi : WindowMediatorSubscriberBase
             var limiterSnapshot = _pairProcessingLimiter.GetSnapshot();
 
             // Check if download notifications are enabled (not set to TextOverlay)
-            var useNotifications = _configService.Current.UseLightlessNotifications
-                ? _configService.Current.LightlessDownloadNotification != NotificationLocation.LightlessUi  
-                : _configService.Current.UseNotificationsForDownloads;
+            var useNotifications =
+                _configService.Current.UseLightlessNotifications &&
+                _configService.Current.LightlessDownloadNotification == NotificationLocation.LightlessUi;
 
             if (useNotifications)
             {